1. It is difficult to generalise the safety of neck massages as they may be performed in a variety of ways.
2. Similarly, chiropractic treatments may encompass a wide range of treatment modalities ranging from neck adjustments (passive neck manipulation) to exercise advice so it is difficult to ascertain its safety.
3. However, it is important for the individual to understand that there are inherent risks associated with such therapies.
Neck massages, which can involve passive manipulation of the cervical spine, carries an inherent risk of causing spinal injuries.
It wasn't too long ago when it was reported in the news that a 20-year-old Thai female singer had died after receiving a neck massage at a massage parlour in Thailand.
If you've ever wondered how safe are neck massages? Or how about neck adjustments performed by a chiropractor, are there long-term risks associated with this? Read on for the answers!
In Singapore, neck pain is very common, affecting all age groups even the young (due to 'text neck' syndrome).
Dr Chen Haobin, Consultant from the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, and Senior Principal physiotherapist Linus Tan, from the Department of Physiotherapy, share more on managing neck pain.
Both Dr Chen and Linus Tan are from Sengkang General Hospital (SKH), a member of the SingHealth group.
How safe are neck massages for neck pain?
“It is difficult to generalise as professional neck massages may be performed in a variety of ways, but people should recognise that passive manipulation of the cervical spine (which occurs when an external party moves your neck) carries an inherent risk of causing spinal injuries,” Dr Chen Haobin said.
“When an individual moves his neck on his own (like when cracking it), the neck movements are kept within his comfort limits without provoking pain or neurological symptoms such as numbness.” Dr Chen explained.
“However, this may not apply to passive manipulation which runs the risk of manipulating the cervical spine beyond the limits of safety, thereby causing or exacerbating underlying injuries. This is particularly a concern for the elderly as well as individuals with underlying osteoporosis,” he added.
Who should avoid going for neck massages?
“Those with pre-existing neurological symptoms (such as numbness in the limbs) as well as those with certain underlying medical conditions (such as osteoporosis, rheumatoid arthritis and ankylosing spondylitis) should avoid neck massages and external neck manipulation,” advised Dr Chen.
Unfortunately, in Singapore, as there are currently no clear guidelines on this subject implemented to date, it very much remains on the part of the individual to weigh the risks and benefits carefully before proceeding with such procedures.
What is your professional opinion on chiropractic adjustments for neck pain?
“Chiropractic treatments may encompass a wide range of treatment modalities ranging from neck adjustments (passive neck manipulation), advise on exercise or stretching routines, to electrical stimulation,” Dr Chen said.
"These (chiropractic neck adjustments) may provide a degree of relief to neck pain in certain cases. However, I feel that it is important for the individual to be aware of the inherent risks associated with passive neck manipulation (similar to neck massages), before making an informed choice in embarking on such therapies,” he added.
When to seek medical help for neck pain
Medical attention is needed for neck pain if you have:
Does mobile phone use affect neck health?
“Contrary to popular belief, neck flexion (the movement of lowering your chin towards your chest or bending your head forward) while using mobile phones is not strongly linked to neck pain.
Research shows that more or less neck flexion does not increase or reduce neck pain risk," shares Senior Principal Physiotherapist Linus Tan.
On factors that do increase risk of neck pain, he shares the following. They include:
To maintain good neck health, he offered some practical tips:
To learn about neck pain treatments offered at SKH and for more tips on neck health, check out this Skoop magazine article!
Ref: G25
Related articles:
Common Causes of Neck and Back Pain